
In the Dressing Room
Why France against South Africa had me glued to the television, while England against Japan couldn’t tempt me away from a family film.
The uncomfortable tension between winning matches and entertaining the people who pay to watch them.
Whether professional teams have a responsibility to entertain, and where we should draw the line between sporting success and spectacle.
I watched France play South Africa over the weekend and was reminded of exactly why I love rugby.
My word, what a game. The mind games, the physicality, the extraordinary skill, the disciplinary drama, the sin bins and the constant sense that something could happen to change the outcome. It was fiercely competitive, occasionally chaotic and absolutely compelling. There were moments when you could barely look away, and others when you wondered quite how either side was going to get through the next ten minutes.
It was everything I want from watching international rugby.
England played Japan over the same weekend. I didn’t even bother watching.
Now, before anyone starts shouting at me, I love the Cherry and Whites. I’ve spent a significant part of my life working in rugby, and I’m certainly not discrediting England, Japan or the players who took to the field. England produced an emphatic victory, scored a remarkable number of tries and gave their supporters plenty to celebrate.
But when it came to deciding how to spend my time, I chose to watch a film with my family instead.
France against South Africa, on the other hand? I wasn’t missing that for anything.
And I think there’s something interesting in that distinction. It wasn’t necessarily about the quality of the rugby I expected to see, or even which team I wanted to win. It was about the prospect of watching a contest where I genuinely didn’t know what was going to happen.
Which got me thinking about something I’ve wrestled with throughout my years working in professional sport.
Does winning matter more than being worth watching?
Because the answer rather depends on who you ask.



